Category Archives: Commentary

Public Officials Deserve Thanks for Protecting Flathead Water

The Friday, March 7, 2008 online edition of the Flathead Beacon published the following commentary by Will Hammerquist, Glacier program manager for the National Parks Conservation Association . . .

Growing up within a bike ride of the Flathead River, I had no idea that my favorite river originated in British Columbia. I just knew that the Flathead River is special and its clean, cold waters were undeniable.

As I grew older, I learned that the three forks of the Flathead come together in Bad Rock Canyon to form the Flathead and that the North Fork is the wildest and most remote of the three.

As an adult, I came to understand that while the Montana portion of the North Fork is one of the most pristine and protected rivers in America, the Canadian headwaters are zoned for mountaintop-removal coalmines, coalbed methane extraction and all other types of metal mining and drilling.

Here in the Flathead, generations of Montanans have long raised concerns over the impacts of these activities on our water, fish and wildlife. Experts warn pollution that from such activities would flow into Glacier National Park within hours and to Flathead Lake within days.

Last month, Montana Sens. Max Baucus and Jon Tester and Gov. Brian Schweitzer held a town-hall meeting to discuss the future of the Canadian headwaters of Flathead River and Flathead Lake. In the past five years, three mountaintop-removal coalmines and two coalbed methane projects have been proposed for the Canadian Flathead.

A packed room of 300 people cheered when Baucus announced that energy giant British Petroleum had abandoned their proposal to develop coalbed methane in the Canadian portion of the Flathead. American democracy and diplomacy was at work. Our elected officials summed up what we all know: Water is Montana’s most precious resource and Glacier’s wildlife, native trout and pristine waters are the fabric of our community, economy and way of life.

Our elected officials – at every level – deserve credit for delivering Montana’s bipartisan voice in the Canadian halls of power and the corporate boardrooms of British Petroleum. Montana concerns are validated as our Canadian neighbors in Fernie, Cranbrook and Elko join with us to protect water quality and wildlife.

While last month’s announcement represents a significant step in our efforts to protect this international treasure – it does not spell victory. Cline Mining Corporation is still promoting a risky and speculative proposal to literally remove a mountain directly above a key North Fork tributary to mine coal for the next 20 years. Another plan is in the works to mine coal under the North Fork riverbed itself.

The acknowledgment of Canadian officials that this area – the heart of the Crown of the Continent – is too special and internationally significant for industrial fossil fuel extraction is a positive development. We all use fossil fuels, but part of responsible energy development is recognizing that some places are just too special to put at risk. The Crown of the Continent is one of those priceless areas.

Now is the time for the provincial and federal governments of Canada to advance a plan for the permanent protection of the Flathead that respects the existing, world-class values of Waterton-Glacier International Peace Park and surrounding landscape for current and future generations.

The National Parks Conservation Association will continue to work with local communities, Montana leaders, and our Canadian neighbors to advocate for a long-term solution.

A welcome victory for Flathead

From the Monday, February 25, 2008 online edition of the Daily Inter Lake . . .

The apparent abandonment of coalbed methane development in the Canadian Flathead should be considered a huge victory for Montana.

British Petroleum announced last week that it would not be pursuing gas development in the drainage, and most importantly, the British Columbia provincial government has chosen the same course.

A provincial official said the Flathead was not included as part of the tenure referral granted to BP last week: “The province recognizes the environmental sensitivity of the Flathead area and has not included this area in the tenure referral.”

That’s big news, because it suggests for the first time a more permanent view of the Canadian Flathead as a natural resource worth protecting.

Read the entire article . . .

Online misbehavior comes to the North Fork

A few months ago, someone noticed that the northforkhostel.com web address actually pointed to the web site of a competitor, the Home Ranch Bottoms. Same for northernlightssaloon.com. The correct address for the hostel is, of course, nfhostel.com and the Northern Lights Saloon has no web site. This generated a certain amount of commentary of the eye-rolling, “give me a break” variety.

Northforkhostel.com now takes you to Montanans For Multiple Use, while northernlightssaloon.com points at a Marine Corp recruiting site.

Sigh . . .

The “Goreacle” and the Great White North

Columnist Joel Connelly takes aim at B.C.’s environmental policies, including their plans for energy development on the Canadian North Fork, in the Friday, September 21, 2007 online edition of the Seattle Post-Intelligencer . . .

As a gloves-off crusader against global warming, ex-Vice President Al Gore has labeled as a “complete and total fraud” the Canadian government’s climate change program.
[…]

What’s going to happen when Gore takes the podium at the Westin Bayshore Hotel in Vancouver next Saturday, Sept. 29th?
[…]

The province has made a much-touted commitment to reduce its current greenhouse gas emissions 33 percent by the year 2020. It pledges a policy of zero net greenhouse gas emissions from existing thermal power generating plants by 2016.
[…]

While pledging to curb emissions from coal-fired power plants, however, British Columbia is feeding Asia’s carbon economy with its coal mines, and acting to facilitate major new mine projects.

It’s a political tactic nicknamed “greenwashing.” Gov. Brian Schweitzer of Montana has called on Premier Campbell to walk his talk.

After soliciting bids, the B.C. government has begun a process that could lead to approval of a massive coal-bed methane project proposed by British Petroleum for the upper headwaters of the Flathead River valley.

Read the entire article . . .

Mining here? It wouldn

From the Wednesday, August 15, 2007 online edition of the Daily Inter Lake . . .

Occasionally, we get correspondence from our good neighbors to the north, claiming that Montanans are hypocritical in opposing mine development in the Canadian Flathead when there is active mine development elsewhere in Montana.

Well, yes, it is true that there is mining in Montana. Gov. Brian Schweitzer is pursuing coalbed methane development as well as coal-to-liquid fuel projects in southeastern Montana. There are also precious metal mines in Montana that are gradually moving forward, despite controversy.

So how can Montanans have the nerve to be concerned about coal extraction in British Columbia

Montana

From the Thursday, July 26, 2007 online edition of the Flathead Beacon . . .

I live almost equally between the Flathead Valley of Montana and the East Kootenays of British Columbia, and have been involved in conservation efforts in the Kootenays for more than 30 years. Consequently, I was bitterly amused to read a recent letter to the Flathead Beacon

Is B.C. premier going ‘green’?

This editorial column from the Thursday, June 7, 2007 online edition of the Seattle Post-Intelligencer provides some background on the political situation in British Columbia regarding environmental matters. About halfway down the article is some commentary on the Cline Mine situation . . .

Is Premier Gordon Campbell genuinely “going green,” or doing a “greenwash” to look good for the Winter Olympics?

Read the entire article . . .